A delicious pizza is a great way to end a day exploring Jekyll Island, Georgia. From casual island restaurants to family-owned pizzerias in nearby coastal towns, visitors have several options for enjoying a relaxed meal.
While Jekyll Island has a limited number of dedicated pizza restaurants, nearby St. Simons Island and Brunswick offer additional choices. If you’re staying in one of our Jekyll Island vacation homes, these restaurants are worth considering during your trip.
Red Bug Motors Pizza on Jekyll Island
Red Bug Motors Pizza is one of the most convenient places to enjoy pizza without leaving Jekyll Island. Located near the island’s miniature golf course, this casual restaurant has served residents and visitors for years.
The restaurant features a comfortable dining room with an Old English pub atmosphere. Guests can dine inside, order takeout, or arrange delivery to eligible locations across Jekyll Island.
For families spending the day at Great Dunes Beach Park or exploring the island’s bike trails, Red Bug Motors Pizza offers an easy dinner option. It’s also a convenient choice for visitors who want to spend less time driving and more time enjoying the island.
Sal’s Neighborhood Pizzeria on St. Simons Island

Sal’s Neighborhood Pizzeria brings traditional Italian cooking to St. Simons Island. Located on Frederica Road, the restaurant specializes in brick-oven pizza prepared using family recipes. The restaurant’s history is connected to former professional boxer Sal Cenicola, who brought his New Jersey roots and Italian cooking traditions to coastal Georgia.
Visitors staying in Jekyll Island vacation rentals can plan an afternoon exploring St. Simons Island before stopping at Sal’s for dinner. The restaurant’s casual atmosphere makes it a welcoming choice for families and groups looking for a relaxed meal.
CJ’s Italian Restaurant on St. Simons Island
CJ’s Italian Restaurant is another excellent option for pizza lovers visiting St. Simons Island. Located on Mallery Street near the village area, this neighborhood restaurant offers Italian cooking in a casual setting. CJ’s emphasizes homemade recipes and offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery ordering options.
Its location makes it convenient for visitors exploring the St. Simons Pier, browsing local shops, or spending an afternoon near the lighthouse. After enjoying the village area, guests can stop for dinner before returning to Jekyll Island.
Fox’s Pizza Den in Brunswick
Fox’s Pizza Den offers a convenient option for travelers exploring historic downtown Brunswick. Located on Newcastle Street, this established pizza chain serves handcrafted pizzas and other casual Italian-American favorites. Its downtown location makes it a practical stop after visiting Brunswick’s shops, historic streets, and waterfront areas.
Visitors staying in Jekyll Island oceanfront villas can also consider Fox’s when planning a day trip to mainland Brunswick. It’s a convenient option for families who want a casual meal before heading back across the causeway.
What Should You Know About Ordering Pizza Near Jekyll Island?
Before choosing among the many Jekyll Island restaurants and nearby dining options, keep a few helpful tips in mind:
- Check delivery areas: Restaurants on St. Simons Island and in Brunswick may not deliver to Jekyll Island.
- Plan for travel: Reaching nearby towns requires driving across the Jekyll Island Causeway and connecting roads.
- Confirm operating hours: Restaurant schedules may change during holidays and slower travel seasons.
- Order ahead: Takeout orders can help reduce waiting during busy dinner periods.
- Consider your plans: If you’re spending the day on Jekyll Island, Red Bug Motors Pizza may be the easiest option. For a day trip, consider restaurants in Brunswick or St. Simons Island.
Plan Your Visit
Ready to discover your new favorite Jekyll Island pizza spot? Choose from our wide selection of Jekyll Island rentals to get started on your next visit!
Final Thoughts
Red Bug Motors Pizza is a convenient choice for staying on Jekyll Island, while Sal’s Neighborhood Pizzeria and CJ’s Italian Restaurant offer additional options on St. Simons Island. Fox’s Pizza Den is another possibility when visiting Brunswick.
Each restaurant provides a different dining experience, making it easy to include a pizza night in your Golden Isles vacation.
Book Your Jekyll Island Vacation Rental with Parker-Kaufman Realtors
At Parker-Kaufman Realtors, we’ve been serving our community for over a century, helping visitors find comfortable accommodations along Georgia’s coast. Our selection includes pet-friendly rentals for guests traveling with their dogs and oceanfront rentals that make enjoying the beach part of your daily routine.
After exploring local restaurants, beaches, and attractions, return to a comfortable vacation home with room to relax. Browse our Jekyll Island vacation properties and book your next coastal getaway with Parker-Kaufman Realtors!
